ING seeks bids on about $500 million of data center loans
ING is seeking buyers for a portfolio of 12 data center loans worth around $500 million, with bids sized at $10 million or more due by 19 November, CNBC reported on 6 November, citing Bloomberg cnbc.com. Three days later Semafor reported that whole portfolios of loans are being shopped at steep discounts, with GPU financings in particular "getting smoked" over worries that the loans will outlive the useful life of the chips, according to one person who spoke to Semafor semafor.com. For a lender weighing a loan against GPUs, and for an owner whose company builds or services data centers, both reports raise the same question: what repays a loan when the collateral loses value faster than the loan runs down.
According to CNBC's account of the Bloomberg report, the ING portfolio includes a $25 million piece linked to the Stargate project in New Mexico, which involves OpenAI, SoftBank and Oracle, along with loan assets involving Vantage Data Centers and CyrusOne. ING will sell through a bids-wanted-in-competition process, in which investors bid on pieces of a loan portfolio. An ING spokesperson declined to comment. Hank Calenti, a global markets strategist at SMBC, told CNBC that investment banks typically use a lend-to-distribute model for these loans, and that whether banks sell more should be driven by the discount they accept against the benefit of freeing cash for further lending.
Semafor's report also quoted Ares Management chief executive Michael Arougheti, who said on a recent earnings call that the firm would pass on GPU financing deals: "I, for one, personally do not know how to underwrite the decline and depreciation curves on that type of technology." The same report said Goldman Sachs and Apollo have started marketing a $40 billion chip financing deal for SpaceX, which Semafor described as the largest of its kind.
A lender that is still making GPU loans published how it does so. On 7 November, Caldrion Private Credit described a closed loan it calls Project Lattice: a $32.0M fully amortizing loan on a 1,024-GPU cluster held by a special purpose vehicle of a Texas-based operator, repaid by a 36-month take-or-pay contract with an investment-grade enterprise software company that reserved the whole cluster at $2.10 per GPU-hour privatecredit.caldrion.com. Caldrion states the loan was 55% of the cluster's installed cost of $58.0M and about 65% of appraised fair market value, priced at S+750, which it puts at about 11.25%, with a 2.00% origination fee and a term matched to the contract. The customer can terminate for convenience only by paying at least the outstanding loan balance, pays into an account Caldrion controls, and half of the excess cash goes to prepaying the loan. Caldrion does not name the borrower or the sponsor, and it says its returns are underwriting targets, not realized results.
Read together, these documents show where lenders to the build-out behind compute now draw the line. Caldrion's Project Lattice is repaid in full during the customer contract, with no reliance on what the chips will fetch later, and its contract terms are written so that the customer cannot leave without paying off the loan. The loans Semafor describes as trading at a discount are the ones whose term may outlast the hardware, and Arougheti's comment names the reason: lenders cannot agree on how fast the equipment loses value. For an operator raising money against a cluster, the signed customer contract, its length and its exit terms now decide whether a loan gets made at all.
For an owner of a services company that installs, powers or maintains data centers, the same test reaches the customer list. A customer whose cluster is funded by a contract-matched loan has a lender who expects to be repaid from that contract, while a customer whose loans are being sold at a discount may face a lender who wants out. The question to ask a large customer is how its equipment is financed and how long its own customer contracts run.
What to watch next is the result of ING's sale after bids close on 19 November, which would be the first public sign of what buyers pay for a pool of data center loans after these reports, and whether Goldman Sachs and Apollo complete the SpaceX financing they are marketing.